Complicated Shoes | Here's a weird question...

Here’s a weird question…

How do you make something like health care… which requires an actual person to provide the care… a right. What if all the doctors decided today not to be doctors anymore? You can’t force people to be doctors. If every doctor in the country determined that this was a raw deal for them and they all moved to Fiji, this would be an unenforceable law, would it not?

Sorry to introduce logic to this discussion.

Carry on.

Posted on March 22, 2010 with 43 notes
1. wooliebear liked this
2. fatben liked this
3. shanshan reblogged this from birdwillbirdwont
4. bunkercomplex liked this
5. boutofcontext liked this
6. spiegelman said: re: “rights are not granted by government”: Government is the only entity that can grant a right to vote. For evidence refer to the past 250 years of American suffrage. Happy to think of several more examples to show how your argument is ridiculous.
7. birdwillbirdwont reblogged this from seanscheidt
8. culby liked this
9. ajamison liked this
10. iambal reblogged this from complicatedshoes
11. iambal liked this
12. complicatedshoes reblogged this from bigbrownbear and added:
  
  Sorry, Skippy. Education is not a right either. This is a prime example of what Randy called the bastardization of the...
13. seanscheidt reblogged this from bigbrownbear and added:
  
  actually..education..roads..and all those...rights. They are luxuries we
14. bigbrownbear reblogged this from seanscheidt and added:
  
  How is health care any different from schools? or the roads? or rednecks forbid the military? I find schools the most...
15. shaunbwilson liked this
16. seanscheidt liked this
17. savvymac liked this
18. savvymac reblogged this from randyhaddock and added:
  
  Can people not see the negatives or do they not care because they don’t see how it is their problem yet?
19. frogsandcandy liked this
20. thediamondage liked this
21. crazynutjob liked this
22. matthewdipaolamd reblogged this from randyhaddock and added:
  
  Good point. I referenced this a little while back but it is worth repeating here. The article is well worth your time....
23. jessarmentrout reblogged this from gaymerlibertarian and added:
  
  THIS IS WHAT I HAVE BEEN TRYING TO TELL PEOPLE. Health care is a commodity, it must be produced, and while there is not...
24. hennnypotter liked this
25. rosa--sparks liked this
26. ringoworld reblogged this from randyhaddock and added:
  
  Guardando alla faccenda da qui, si nota la grande lontananza che separa noi da loro. Parlando di “rights” e “person” con...
27. acrazymomslife reblogged this from complicatedshoes
28. acrazymomslife liked this
29. booyagrandma liked this
30. gaymerlibertarian reblogged this from complicatedshoes
31. moneyissues liked this
32. gaymerlibertarian liked this
33. cf1 liked this
34. disasterrpiece liked this
35. cellophanesoul reblogged this from randyhaddock and added:
  
  As Dwight says (from The Office), “In the wild, there is no health care.”
36. cellophanesoul liked this
37. thedailyfiona said: I think they truly believe it’s a right. It comes with the lack of personal responsibility and accountability for one’s place in society.
38. inmywardrobe liked this
39. randyhaddock reblogged this from complicatedshoes and added:
  
  things I most resent about...whole health care debacle is how the concept of rights has...
40. nolagrrlnyc liked this
41. onemoretimewithfeeling liked this
42. randyhaddock liked this
43. complicatedshoes posted this